TLDR Review: "Wheat Penny Roll with Mercury Dime"
Pros
- •Includes a 90% silver Mercury dime, which is often highlighted as a key valuable coin in the lot.
- •Some rolls come with rare coins like Indian Head pennies or wheat cents from early 1900s (e.g., 1906, 1889), adding collector appeal.
- •Recent purchases have shown improvement in coin quality and inclusion of desirable dates such as 1914, 1919, 1924, 1926, and 1932.
- •The Mercury dime, even if circulated, adds good bait or collectible interest for many buyers.
- •Felt bag packaging adds a nice touch and keeps coins together neatly.
- •The presence of a bonus rare penny alongside the roll feels like extra value.
- •Buyers new to coin collecting report positive experiences and some intend to make repeat purchases.
- •Helps build a basic collection of mixed circulated vintage US coins, especially useful for casual collectors.
Cons
- •Majority of wheat pennies are heavily circulated and mostly from the 1940s and 1950s, which limits variety for serious collectors.
- •Some rolls appear picked over or artificially assembled, reducing authenticity and overall coin quality.
- •Claims about widanging coin dates (1800s through 1958) are misleading—most coins come from mid-20th century and later.
- •Many pennies show significant wear, rust, or washed appearance, detracting from collector value.
- •Limited inclusion of Indian Head pennies and almost no steel pennies despite advertising suggestions.
- •Mercury dimes included are sometimes in poor condition with edge and surface wear.
- •Better coin variety and quality often found via auctions or specialized sellers rather than this lot.
- •Inconsistent roll wrapping and coin assortments diminish the "unsearched" claim and collector excitement.
- •The product is less suited for those seeking higrade or rare coins; more for casual or bulk hunting purposes.
Bottom Line
This wheat penny roll with a silver Mercury dime end offers decent starter value, especially for casual collectors and those intrigued by the silver dime bonus. However, the heavy presence of circulated mid-20th century pennies and some disappointment around the “unsearched” claim means serious collectors may want to look elsewhere for better variety and condition. If your goal is building a casual, budget-friendly coin assortment with a splash of vintage charm, this lot can be a fun pick. For more dependable high-quality selections or specialized dates, consider exploring auction lots or dedicated coin dealers.
Download ShopSavvy App
Compare prices for anything in real-time, set price alerts, watch for deals by keyword, and much more
Install ShopSavvy Browser Extension
Compare and track prices automatically while you shop online at thousands of websites.
Footer 1
Subscribe for Updates
Get the latest news, and updates on ShopSavvy. You'll be glad you did!